Read the full version

Alperea Assurances

Challenging a CPAM reimbursement refusal: choosing an appeal route

CPAM reimbursement refusal: read the notification to choose between an administrative and a medical appeal, then identify the steps and deadlines.

By Sabri Hamda · Insurance brokerUpdated on 6 min read
In this article

To challenge a CPAM reimbursement refusal, start by reading the notification and the reason for the decision. A refusal to reimburse healthcare costs is an example of an administrative decision: you must first appeal to your fund’s commission de recours amiable (CRA). For a medical decision, you must appeal to the commission médicale de recours amiable (CMRA).

The starting point is therefore the nature of the decision being challenged. The steps and deadlines that follow differ depending on the commission you appeal to. This guide provides general information: also refer to the instructions in your notification when preparing your appeal.

Read the notification before choosing an appeal route

Identify the decision you wish to challenge, its reason and the date on which it was notified. Ameli gives a refusal to reimburse healthcare costs as an example of an administrative decision. Among its examples of medical decisions, Ameli cites the date on which a person’s health condition stabilises and classification in a disability category.

The distinction matters: look at what the fund actually decided. If you are unsure when reading the letter, keep the precise reason in mind when identifying the appeal route.

The notification also serves as a reference for the appeal deadline. For the CMRA, it also gives the address to which the appeal must be sent, and a copy must be included with the request. Keep the letter so that you can find these details and the instructions it contains.

Administrative refusal: appeal to the CRA first

To challenge an administrative decision, such as a refusal to reimburse healthcare costs or pay daily allowances, you must first appeal to the CRA of your health insurance fund. The procedure is free.

Send the request

Send your request by ordinary letter to your fund’s CRA within 2 months of the date on which the contested decision was notified. Before sending it, check that your letter makes it possible to identify the decision you are challenging and that you have identified the notification date used to calculate the deadline.

The CRA decides on the basis of the documents; you will not be summoned. Its decision will be notified to you by letter, along with the appeal routes and deadlines. It is therefore useful to keep the request and watch for the response so that you can read these instructions.

If the CRA rejects the request or does not respond

If the CRA rejects your request, you can appeal to the social division of the tribunal judiciaire within 2 months of the date on which its rejection was notified. If the CRA does not respond within 2 months of receiving your request, this also means that it has been rejected. Once that period has expired, you have 2 months to appeal to the social division of the tribunal judiciaire.

To distinguish between these situations, note both the date on which the CRA received your request and, if you receive a response, the date on which its decision was notified. Notification of the rejection and expiry of the response period are separate starting points for appealing to the court.

Medical decision: appeal to the CMRA

To challenge a medical decision, you must appeal to the CMRA. Ameli gives as examples the date on which a person’s health condition stabilises, classification in a disability category or the assignment of a permanent partial disability rate.

The CMRA has regional jurisdiction: the one that handles the case is the one in whose jurisdiction your health insurance fund’s head office is located. Its address appears on the notification of the contested decision.

Prepare the letter and a copy of the decision

Send your request by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt to the CMRA, stating your grounds for challenging the decision and enclosing a copy of the notification. You have 2 months from the date on which the contested decision was notified to appeal to it.

In your letter, distinguish the contested decision from your reasons for challenging it: these grounds are among the details you must provide. Also check that the enclosed copy is of the relevant notification and that the address used is the one given on it.

Review of the case and response

The commission decides on the basis of the documents. However, it may decide to examine you: you will then be summoned at least 15 days before the examination and may be accompanied by a doctor of your choice.

After the session, the CMRA gives an opinion on your request. Your fund’s decision, in accordance with that opinion, will be notified to you by letter along with the appeal routes and deadlines. Read these instructions as soon as you receive them to determine how you wish to proceed with the case.

If the CMRA rejects your request, you can appeal to the social division of the tribunal judiciaire within 2 months of the notification date. If the CMRA does not respond within 4 months of receiving your request, this means that it has been rejected. Once that period has expired, you have 2 months to appeal to the social division of the tribunal judiciaire.

After the commission: consider the tribunal judiciaire

You can challenge a decision made by the CRA or the CMRA before the social division of the tribunal judiciaire. The court with jurisdiction depends on where you live; its address is given, where applicable, on the acknowledgement of receipt or the commission’s decision and by the fund.

The application may be filed with the court registry or sent by registered letter to the address given on the notification of the contested commission decision. The deadline is 2 months: it runs from notification of the commission’s decision or, if there is no response, from expiry of the period the commission had to respond.

Bringing a case before the tribunal judiciaire may require payment of a 50 € stamp duty. If you are not satisfied with the court’s decision, an appeal and/or an appeal in cassation may be considered under the applicable procedures. To choose what to do next, read the decision you receive and its appeal instructions.

A simple check before sending

  • Read the reason in the notification again: determine whether the contested decision is administrative or medical.
  • Identify the commission to appeal to: CRA for an administrative decision, CMRA for a medical decision.
  • Identify the notification date and prepare to send your request within the applicable deadline.
  • For the CMRA, state your grounds, enclose a copy of the notification and use the address given on it.
  • Keep the letters and record the relevant dates to follow up on the response and, if necessary, consider what to do next.
Our clients’ reviews on Google 5.0/5 · 128 Google reviews Recorded on
20 free calculators and quote tools