In this article
To prepare an application for a supplementary family allowance between France and Switzerland, start by identifying where each parent works and where the children live. When one parent works in Switzerland and the other works in France, where they live with the child, French entitlement takes priority. A Swiss allowance is payable if Swiss benefits are higher than those of the country of residence.
These guidelines are not enough to determine individual entitlement or establish the list of supporting documents required. Present your situation to the relevant authorities and ask them to specify which documents to provide. This guide helps you prepare for that discussion and distinguish the question of priority from that of a possible supplementary allowance.
Understanding priority between countries
Switzerland applies social security coordination rules with European Union states under the agreement on the free movement of persons. This agreement covers family benefits among other things.
According to the Federal Social Insurance Office, a person is entitled to benefits from the country in which they work, even if they live with their children in another state. But if the other parent lives in the same country as the child and also works there, entitlement to benefits from that state takes priority.
For a family living in France, the other parent’s employment situation should therefore be examined before seeking to determine which authority may provide a supplementary allowance. Clearly tell the authorities where each parent works and where the child lives: these details allow you to present the case without confusing the place of work with the place of residence.
To prepare your application, keep these details separate in your notes. Write down the country of employment next to each parent, then the country of residence of each parent and the child. This will help you explain the situation consistently to the French and Swiss authorities, even if you write to them separately.
When might a supplementary allowance be payable?
When the other parent lives and works in the child’s country of residence, the other state grants an allowance if its benefits are higher than those of the country of residence. For the case described above, Swiss benefits must therefore be examined in comparison with benefits from the country of residence, France.
Do not treat this guideline as an estimate of your supplementary allowance. Ask the authorities to check the entitlements and amounts applicable to your family. Keep their replies so you can distinguish what concerns priority from what concerns a possible allowance from the other state.
In your discussions, ask the questions separately: first ask which entitlement takes priority in your situation, then how to have the allowance from the other state assessed. If you have already received a reply about family benefits, keep it handy so you can explain what has been examined and what remains to be checked. Avoid anticipating an amount before you have received a reply specific to your application.
Gather information before requesting the list of documents
Prepare a simple account of your family and employment situation. You can use it to ask the French and Swiss authorities the same questions, then complete your application according to their instructions.
- Specify the child’s country of residence and that of each parent.
- State the country where each parent works and explain whether the situation has changed.
- Note the family benefits already identified and the replies received from the authorities.
- Ask which supporting documents correspond to this information and how to submit them.
This list is intended to help you prepare for your discussions: it does not replace an official list of documents. The available extracts specify neither a form nor a mandatory supporting document for this application. Before sending anything, have the authority you are contacting confirm the documents expected and the recipient.
You can prepare a record of the information to be checked rather than selecting documents yourself and assuming they will be accepted. For each item of information you provide, ask the authority whether it wants a supporting document and which one. If it tells you how to submit it, note this alongside its reply so you can easily find its instructions when completing the application.
Check whether your situation falls within the framework described
The agreement applies to Swiss and European Union nationals who are or have been insured in Switzerland or in the Community area, as well as to refugees and stateless persons. Their family members and survivors are also covered.
If your situation does not clearly fit this framework, explain it to the authorities rather than assuming that the example presented applies. Also mention any particular circumstances concerning employment or residence, so that they can examine your application in context.
When making your request, distinguish what you know from what you want confirmed. For example, state the places of employment and residence, then ask whether the framework described applies to your family. This check is useful before drawing a conclusion about priority or a possible allowance.
Questions to ask the authorities
- Given where the parents work and where the child lives, which entitlement takes priority in our situation?
- What information and supporting documents would you like to receive to examine this entitlement?
- How can we have a possible allowance from the other state assessed if its benefits are higher?
- Which details from your reply must we send to the other authority?
As you receive replies, file them with the corresponding questions. If a reply seems incomplete, restate the details of your situation and ask the relevant authority for clarification. You can then prepare the next steps of your application based on its instructions, rather than interpreting a general rule on your own.
Ask for a reply specific to your family before concluding that the supplementary allowance is due or anticipating its amount. This guide provides general information, not a decision on your entitlements.