Read the full version

Alperea Assurances

Evidence of identity theft: what should you gather before filing a complaint?

What evidence should you gather in cases of identity theft? Prepare your complaint, distinguish it from a police incident report and identify the organisations to notify.

By Sabri Hamda · Insurance brokerUpdated on 6 min read
In this article

To prepare for a procedure involving identity theft evidence, gather the items that show what you have observed: screenshots, messages, addresses of the pages concerned and repayment requests. The complaint must be accompanied by all the evidence, including these items. Organise them around the facts you can describe, distinguishing a suspicion from an instance where you have already observed your identity being used.

This guide provides information to help you prepare for the steps you take and your communications with the organisations concerned. It is general information that should be considered in the context of your personal situation.

Start with the facts: suspicion or observed use?

Identity theft consists of using a person’s identifying information or personal data without their consent for a malicious purpose. It can take the form of taking out credit or a subscription, among other things. It can also occur online.

Losing an identity document or sending personal documents in response to a fake job advertisement may give rise to suspicion. Discovering a repayment request for credit you did not take out, on the other hand, is an example of a situation in which a victim can file a complaint.

Before preparing your case, state precisely what you know: which document was lost or sent? What message or request did you receive? If you have observed your data being used, explain how you know. This distinction will help you present your situation and choose the appropriate course of action.

What evidence should you gather for the complaint?

Service Public states that the complaint must be accompanied by all the evidence: screenshots, messages, addresses of the internet pages concerned and repayment requests from organisations, for example. Gather those relevant to your situation and keep them available to present alongside your account.

  • Communications received: gather messages and repayment requests relating to the facts you dispute.
  • Online evidence: keep screenshots and addresses of the internet pages concerned.
  • Account of the facts: prepare details of the nature, date and place of the events when known. These are among the details recorded in a police incident report.

You can sort these items by subject to make it easier to find the document corresponding to each event: for example, a repayment request with the related messages, or a screenshot with the address of the page concerned. Distinguish what you have personally observed from questions that remain to be clarified.

To check certain indications, Service Public suggests, among other things, examining your bank statements, watching for penalty notices for an offence you did not commit and searching for your name using a search engine. These checks can guide your preparation: note anything that seems unusual and link it, if possible, to the document or page you have kept.

Police incident report or criminal complaint: what is the difference?

If you suspect possible identity theft, a police incident report may be filed, for example after a cyberattack or the loss of an identity document. The report is made at a police station or gendarmerie. The facts, including their nature, date and place, are recorded in a police or gendarmerie register.

The police incident report may be used to establish when the events occurred or as supporting evidence in future criminal proceedings. If you wish to have a situation recorded, report or disclose events of which you are a victim but without criminal proceedings against the perpetrator, you must file a police incident report.

A police incident report and a criminal complaint serve different purposes. If you believe you are the victim of a criminal offence and want the perpetrator to be prosecuted, you must file a complaint. A victim can file a complaint as soon as they realise that an offence has been committed. Prepare the evidence alongside your account, indicating the points you can substantiate.

Which organisations should you notify based on the facts?

When the identity theft concerns financial matters, the victim must notify the banks or financial institutions concerned, including any credit company. To prepare for this exchange, review the request or transaction in question and explain why you dispute it.

The victim can consult the register of bank and similar accounts, called Ficoba, to obtain a list of bank accounts opened in their name. They can also consult the Banque de France files relating to cheques and credit repayment incidents. These checks address different questions: prepare your communications based on the irregularity you are trying to understand.

The victim can provide a sworn statement to the organisations holding them responsible, declaring that they did not commit the acts, and attach a copy of their complaint. Support your explanation with the relevant documents and distinguish the dispute you submit to the organisation from the criminal procedure.

In administrative matters, the victim must inform the administrations and organisations concerned, including social security, the pension fund, the supplementary health insurer or the tax authorities. If you are preparing to contact a supplementary health insurer, identify the facts and documents that concern that organisation. Adapt your presentation to the area affected and the person or organisation you are contacting.

What if the identity theft appears online or in a penalty notice?

In cases of online identity theft, the victim can file a complaint and report the identity theft directly to the platforms concerned. They can request the removal of the malicious publication. The Cnil can help them deal with website operators regarding the protection of personal data.

Before contacting a platform, gather screenshots and addresses of the pages concerned: these are among the pieces of evidence cited by Service Public to accompany a complaint. Also prepare a clear description of what you observed and of the publication you are asking to be removed.

A victim who receives a penalty notice for an act they did not commit can file a complaint for identity theft or vehicle registration plate cloning. They must dispute the fine. Keep the notice with the items needed to explain the situation and distinguish this dispute from the complaint.

Prepare for the next steps without exposing more data

For future submissions, Service Public recommends, among other things, adding a personalised marking, or watermark, to scanned documents sent to an administration or an organisation. If you have doubts about the sender of a message, it also recommends checking the website by manually entering its address in the browser.

Finally, review your case before each exchange: the event concerned, the related document and the action you wish to take. For a complaint, gather all the evidence; for an organisation, set out the facts that concern it and, if you make a sworn statement, attach a copy of your complaint.

Our clients’ reviews on Google 5.0/5 · 128 Google reviews Recorded on
20 free calculators and quote tools