To compare two car insurance proposals, start by identifying the cover you want in each: driver protection, damage, assistance and breakdown assistance. Then note what the documents supplied provide, their limits and the points that need clarification. Only after doing this can you examine the prices in light of the cover offered.
The owner or driver of a motor vehicle travelling in France must have at least third-party liability insurance. This basic cover alone does not answer the practical question that concerns you: what other protections would you like to request? The method below helps you prepare for your discussions; it does not replace a review of the documents applicable to your situation.
Start with the same request for both proposals
You can freely contact several agents at the same time to compare their proposals. To make them easier to review, give each one the same list of requirements and describe your situation consistently. This will make it easier to see whether a difference comes from your request or from the response provided.
Service Public states that you must tell the insurer you take out cover with what type of cover you want: third-party liability, material damage, driver protection, assistance or breakdown assistance, for example. Before requesting proposals, note the protections that matter to you and those you would like explained. You can also rank your questions by priority, without presuming the insurer’s response.
Prepare information about your situation
The insurer may ask you to complete a questionnaire to assess the risks and calculate the premium. Service Public advises, in particular, that you disclose use of the vehicle to travel to work, the identity of regular drivers, major accidents and penalties incurred in the past. The information provided to the insurer must be accurate.
Keep this information to hand before your discussions. If you were previously insured, you will need to provide a statement of information issued by your previous insurer. If a question seems ambiguous, ask how to answer it rather than assuming what is expected.
Gather the documents before comparing
The insurer you approach must provide an insurance proposal including a copy of the draft contract, an information sheet on prices and cover, and a detailed information notice. Ask for these items for each proposal so that you can read them side by side.
The documents must be clear and written in prominent print. They provide information on cover limits, including the list of risks not covered. For your comparison, note the wording of each useful passage and keep a reference to the document where you found it. If a point remains difficult to understand, note it as a question to ask rather than taking it for granted.
Examine the protections before the prices
Third-party liability and driver protection
Start by identifying the third-party liability cover in each proposal, then look separately for the driver protection you requested. Do not rely solely on the presence of a heading: read the passages devoted to it and the relevant limits.
For each proposal, note what you understand about the driver protection and the points that need clarification. If the wording differs, ask each person you are dealing with to explain their proposal using the documents provided. This will help you distinguish a difference in presentation from a difference in protection.
Damage, assistance and breakdown assistance
Follow the same approach for material damage, then for assistance and breakdown assistance. Return to your list of requirements and check where each of these subjects appears in the documents. Note any differences in wording and the associated limits, without assuming that an identical term necessarily represents the same response to your request.
To make the discussion concrete, ask one question at a time: “Where is the requested protection described?”, “What are its limits?” or “Can you explain this passage to me?”. Record the answer next to the relevant proposal, with a reference to the passage discussed. If you want to change your request, present the change to the people concerned before resuming the comparison.
Limits and exclusions: retain the context
The notice and the other documents provided should also be read for their cover limits, particularly the list of risks not covered. Identify the passages concerning the protections you requested. A list of headings, without reading the limits, is not enough to carry out the comparison you want to make.
Copy useful wording along with its context: a limit may apply to a type of cover or to a specific situation. If you do not know how a passage applies to your case, ask for an explanation before drawing a conclusion. You can then check that you are comparing the answers to the same questions in both proposals.
Build a simple comparison table
Prepare a row for each subject and a column for each proposal. Add a “question” column for anything that remains to be confirmed. The table does not need to replace the documents: it helps you quickly find passages to reread and organise your discussions.
- Third-party liability: where does it appear in each proposal?
- Driver protection: which passages address your request and which limits need clarification?
- Material damage: where are the desired cover and its limits described?
- Assistance and breakdown assistance: what responses are provided to your request and which points still need clarification?
- Cover limits: which risks not covered need to be read in context?
- Price: what amount is stated in each information sheet, once the cover and its limits have been examined?
An empty cell or wording you do not understand becomes a question to put to the insurer. Once you have received the answers, return to your table and check whether they still match your original request. If the protections offered differ, keep that difference visible when looking at prices: the amounts alone do not describe what you requested.
Clarify before signing
This approach is intended to help you prepare a decision, not to take out cover on your behalf. Take the time to reread the documents and have the points that matter to you clarified. Service Public states that once the signed proposal reaches the insurer, the contract is formed and you can no longer reverse your decision.
The right of withdrawal varies according to how the contract is concluded. For example, Service Public specifies that the 14-day right of withdrawal provided for contracts concluded off-premises may apply to a car insurance contract signed at your home or workplace following an approach by the insurer; it applies only if you have not made use of any of the cover under the contract. Before signing, therefore, check the position for your method of concluding the contract and ask your remaining questions.
